Wednesday 06/12/2013 by bl002e

REVISITING CANADA (TORONTO)

It’s hard to process the fact that July 6 will mark the passage of thirteen years since the last time the nation of Canada – or any land outside of the Unites States, for that matter – hosted a Phish show. A variety of theories abound to explain the lengthy embargo, from previous border-crossing difficulties, to Trey’s probationary terms stemming from his December 2006 arrest, to the band’s devotion to Dunkin’ Donuts and utter contempt for Tim Hortons.

Regardless of the actual reasoning, it will come to an end a mere three days following that milestone. That roar you vaguely remember coming down from north of the border this past winter? Well, okay – it was almost certainly the celebration of professional hockey’s return from yet another labor stoppage. But there’s a slim chance it was the long-neglected Canadian contingency of Phish fans cheering the announcement of the upcoming July 9, 2013 show at Toronto’s Molson Canadian Amphitheatre.

The band’s history in Canada originated with yet another early July show. On July 1, 1989 as part of the Montréal International Jazz Festival, Phish played a one-set show at les Foufounes Électriques. Because a recording does not appear to circulate, it’s unfortunately impossible to determine if the playing lived up to the venue’s translated name of “The Electric Buttocks”. However, the setlist does provoke some curiosity. It’s a bit surprising that, given their late-1980s jazz-heavy rotation, “Donna Lee” was the band’s only jazz cover they chose to play. And perhaps more notably, the encore featured what might be Phish’s a cappella debut, with a vocals-only take on Led Zeppelin’s “Immigrant Song”.

Considering Burlington is less than an hour from the border, it’s somewhat surprising that almost three and a half years passed before Phish’s next Canadian jaunt. Their debut headlining international gig occurred on December 12, 1992 in Toronto, followed the next day by a return appearance in Montréal, both at venues named the (le) Spectrum. The short-list of highlights of the 1992 Fall Tour’s closing pair of shows are dominated by the brilliant first night, with compact-yet-rousing versions of “Reba” and “Split Open and Melt”, an exploratory-for-its-time “Tweezer”, and the first “Ride Captain Ride” in 337 shows (and the next-to-last version played until 1998).

Possibly encouraged by this experience, the next two years included five Canadian shows apiece, accounting for a whopping ten of the eighteen they’ve played there to date. Western Canada hosted its first Phish show on April 3, 1993 at the 86th Street Music Hall in Vancouver, containing a rollicking 27-minute “You Enjoy Myself”, which from a glance at PhishTracks.com appears to be the longest version played up to that point. As the vocal jam wound down, Trey whispered “Mr. Neil Young”, perhaps as a nod to their future collaborator’s Canadian origins. Continuing this trend later that month, the second set of April 27’s show at the Concert Hall in Toronto featured teases of “Sundown” and “The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald”, two of Ontario-native singer-songwriter Gordon Lightfoot’s best-known songs. Two days later on the 29th, Phish returned to play Montréal’s Le Spectrum for the second and last time, with a performance best remembered for its blistering version of “Run Like an Antelope” and a “Weekapaug Groove” bookending the return of “Makisupa Policeman”, not seen in 322 previous shows.

Phish’s 1993 Summer Tour represents a historical landmark in their capacity for improvisation, most notably the nineteen August shows of the tour’s thirty-three. On August 9, its second show at the Concert Hall, a since-closed live music club located in Toronto’s Masonic Temple, the band opened with a “Chalk Dust Torture” that seamlessly sandwiched a foray into the Band of Gypsys’ “Who Knows”. The second-set “You Enjoy Myself” is just one of that monumental month’s many jams that show four musicians willing to go to its most eccentric extremes, seemingly incapable of self-consciousness, as they sang “Here Comes Speed Racer” over musical teases of Deep Purple’s “Smoke on the Water” before masterfully segueing the subsequent vocal jam – containing lyrics from Talking Heads’ “Psycho Killer” – into “Contact”. The show played at Vancouver’s Commodore Ballroom on August 24 featured less wackiness, but a greater success rate in terms of its jamming excursions. In light of that month’s numerous top-shelf editions of “Split Open and Melt” and “Run Like an Antelope”, the ones played on this day could be easy to overlook, but they’re both worthy of your attention. And both “Mike’s Song” and “Weekapaug Groove” venture well inside type-II territory.

Another trek across the continent begat another three Canadian concerts with the 1994 Spring Tour. After opening the tour at the Flynn in Burlington, Phish played the next two nights at the Metropolis in Montréal (April 5) and their third and last-ever performance at the Concert Hall (April 6). The short-yet-melodic Montréal “Tweezer” and the building, swirling Toronto “Stash” stood out as each show’s high point, as the pair of shows function as a microcosm of a majority of the month that followed – musically acceptable, yet lacking the adventurousness of the previous summer. As tour trucks and buses hit Vancouver less than seven weeks later, the band’s confidence level was beginning an upswing, no doubt bolstered by what transpired during the second set at The Bomb Factory in Dallas a mere fifteen days prior. On May 22, for the only time in Phish’s history, “Demand” was the opening song played, fittingly at their lone show at the gorgeous Vogue Theatre. Later that initial set brought another simmering Vancouver “Split Open and Melt”, followed by an acoustic, unamplified trio of songs, a trend they continued throughout the year at intimate venues that displayed their burgeoning interest in bluegrass. Set two further testified to Phish’s ability to alternate melting brains with healing souls, but to much greater effect – the majestic Page-led “McGrupp and the Watchful Hosemasters” jam found its way to an incendiary “Tweezer” climax, segueing into a moving “Lifeboy”, furious “Rift”, soothing “Slave to the Traffic Light”, and an exhilarating “Tweezer Reprise” closer. Mastering ultimate control of the energy at any moment at any concert now appeared to be an attainable achievement by the band.

If their previous seven-week period of improvement can be viewed as analogous to the climbing of a mountain, please consider the progress made by Phish in the seven subsequent weeks a shot into orbit. Almost a month into the exceptional 1994 Summer Tour, the band’s momentum was unstoppable. July 5 at the Congress Centre – to date their only tour stop at Canada’s capital city – was an instant classic, highlighted by the first “Letter to Jimmy Page” in 357 shows, a wonderfully deranged “Stash”, unrelenting “Bathtub Gin”, and a rare “Cities”, not played in 674 previous shows and not seen again for another 222. Somehow, they found a way to best this performance the following night at the Théâtre St-Denis, with astonishingly brilliant takes on “David Bowie”, “Tweezer”, and “Harry Hood” at their last appearance in Montréal. Yet even these are topped by what I consider the true crème de la crème of all eighteen Canadian shows: the Montréal “Reba”. Phish’s premier piece of improvisational music produced in the true north strong and free. This jam is HOSE incarnate. And if you disagree … well … you can just take off, you hoser.

As with each of the six Phish has played in the city of Vancouver, British Columbia, the October 6, 1995 concert took place at a specific venue for the first and last time. This particular time, the choice of location was the Orpheum Theatre. Not much sticks out from this show, quite honestly. The fifteen months since their last trip northward were monumental. They inaugurated a Halloween tradition by donning a musical costume, covering the Beatles’ White Album. They’d pushed their willingness to experiment as far as they could, epitomized by the Bozeman and Mud Island “Tweezers” and Minneapolis and Providence “David Bowies”. Their most-recent album release was their first of many live ones. And perhaps most significantly, with the death of Jerry Garcia and demise of the Grateful Dead, Phish became the media-appointed successors to the jam-band throne. It’s little wonder that the start of their massive 54-show 1995 Fall Tour found the band catching its collective breath; at its lone Canadian stop, occurring in the second of its nearly twelve weeks, the highlights are scarce. If you’re compelled to check the show out, I advise taking a direct path to its face-melting rendition of “Maze”.

Phish found themselves in a similar situation the following fall, as their popularity in North American culture continued its meteoric rise. Their lone 1996 Fall Tour appearance in the North America North of America was once again located at a one-time-only Vancouver venue, and with a maximum capacity of over 17,000, the Pacific Coliseum was easily the largest they’d played in Canada to that point. The November 23, 1996 show is possibly most noteworthy for what occurred before the show at the U.S.-Canada border crossing, alluded to during that night’s “Makisupa Policeman”. During their lengthy wait at the border, Mike taught the rest of the band Hot Rize’s apropos “Midnight on the Highway”. While you’re at it, be sure to check out the show’s excellent “Weekapaug Groove”.

Likely having more to do with a newfound attempt at strengthening their foothold in Europe than with any trauma still lingering from the confiscation of dank miscellanea incident, nearly three years passed until their next Canadian show. On July 20, 1999, Phish’s inaugural Molson Canadian Amphitheatre show became their first in Toronto in over five years. A criminally-underrated “Ghost” and the persistent funk of “You Enjoy Myself” helped anchor a massive first set that exceeded ninety minutes, overshadowing a second set that found the band mostly eschewing boldness in favor of playing it safe within the confines of a spacefunk-lite soundscape. Ultimately, the closer to this set packed a wallop, as the debut of Led Zeppelin’s “Misty Mountain Hop” was typical of numerous 1999 Summer Tour jams, building ecstatic peak on top of ecstatic peak, contrasting sharply with that tour’s other penchant for delicate, narcotic grooving. The subsequent 1999 Fall Tour combined these two extremes, with a dab of good ol’ rock ‘n roll evilness mixed in for good measure. With their first North American tour to kick off outside of the continental Unites States, Phish employed this style of improv to great effect at the September 9, 1999 opener at General Motors Place in Vancouver. Both the first-set “Stash” and second-set “Tweezer” brilliantly exemplified this swirling, churning, visceral approach that dominated many of the musical peaks they’d reach throughout the next year.

Although the Summer 2000 edition of the Doniac Schvice indicated a New Year’s run would follow the upcoming month-long fall tour, rumors of an extended hiatus persisted both online and at 2000 Summer Tour stops, likely originating from a Rolling Stone interview with Trey the previous fall. However, I’d be shocked if anyone attending the July 6, 2000 show truly believed it’d be well over a decade before Phish returned to America’s neighbo(u)r to the north. As had occurred at their previous show at the Molson, an immense set one – ten minutes short of two hours! – outshined a comparatively weaker second set. Though no match for the one played exactly six years earlier in Montréal, an enchanting “Reba” opened a Phish show for the first time since 1992. Later in the set brought another rarity – “The Moma Dance” with its closing riff leading to an extended jam. As it did a year earlier, a pulsating “You Enjoy Myself” led the Toronto crowd to set break. Set two delivered strong versions of “Limb by Limb” and “Piper” that are surely worth listening to. Pacing and energy in the homestretch proved to be a problem, however – issues that would often vex the band’s performances throughout the last two years of the “1.0” era.

Given the previous eighteen Canadian Phish shows, what can attendees of show number nineteen expect? If the previous setlists and the show statistics indicate any trends, don’t expect to see a “Possum”, “Fire”, “Forbin’s”/”Mockingbird”, or “Tube”. Going by the previous two Molson shows, make sure to take care of those preshow XXXs before the lights go down, because it’ll be a long time to wait for the “YEM” vocal jam to segue into setbreak. Finally, although located right off the coast of Lake Ontario, don’t expect to be blown away by the aesthetics of the venue. Having attended both previous Molson shows, I quite honestly can’t remember a single quality, good or bad, the amphitheatre has to offer. Instead, if you’re travelling to the show, you’d be well-off taking the time to explore the best that Toronto has to offer.

If you liked this blog post, one way you could "like" it is to make a donation to The Mockingbird Foundation, the sponsor of Phish.net. Support music education for children, and you just might change the world.


Comments

, comment by davethewall
davethewall BUT, Trey and Mike played in Toronto with the Benevento/Russo duo in 2006.
, comment by bl002e
bl002e @davethewall said:
BUT, Trey and Mike played in Toronto with the Benevento/Russo duo in 2006.
Excellent point, Dave. And that would obviously lead one to believe Page or Fishman to be the mystery Tim Hortons detractor.
, comment by andrewrose
andrewrose An excellent and thorough tribute to Phish's history in Canada, @bl002e. Nice touch to extend the piece to the rest of the country and not just Toronto.

What's harder to fathom in the Canadian question is that July 6th will also mark the 19th anniversary of the last show in Montreal, my first show, and hence the only one I've seen in my hometown. I still remember Fishman sitting a few rows ahead of me at the Elvin Jones/McCoy Tyner show during the jazz fest, which was I think the day after. Anyway fingers crossed they'll make it back here for the 20 year anniversary. Not holding my breath, but .. this is definitely the best party town in Canada. Would make for a helluva good time.

I was out of the country in 2000 but Toronto 99 was a hot affair. Wouldn't mind a nod to that show and a Misty Mountain Hop bustout. I think we'll hear a Reba, and maybe an Albuquerque. I can't wait.

, comment by Mcgrupp223
Mcgrupp223 "Finally, although located right off the coast of Lake Erie, don’t expect to be blown away by the aesthetics of the venue."

FAIL! Toronto is on lake Ontario!
, comment by funkbeard
funkbeard Great read. I reflect on the wonder that is 8/9/93 Melt> Glide. Tempo changes, secret.language, and a perfect segue.
, comment by lumpblockclod
lumpblockclod Nice write-up, @Bl002e. Agree that the 7/6/94 Reba is the best thing to come out of the Canadian shows (and, more broadly, 7/5-6/94 are the best two Canadian shows). Just so much great stuff throughout those shows. 8/9/93 is also great, though it resides squarely in the meaty part of the August '93 bell curve. In any event, great to see them returning to Canada. A Montreal show would be great. Some European shows would be even better...
, comment by andrewrose
andrewrose By the way, Foufounes Electrique still exists. It's a classic dirty dive venue downtown frequented by a mostly punk-French crowd. Despite the show being programmed as part of the Jazz fest, there's nothing jazzy about the place. To give you an idea, Nirvana played their first Montreal show there a couple years later. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oI2XTmvaNBk
, comment by bl002e
bl002e Thanks for the kind words, @andrewrose @funkbeard@lumpblockclod.

@Mcgrupp223 said:
"Finally, although located right off the coast of Lake Erie, don�t expect to be blown away by the aesthetics of the venue."

FAIL! Toronto is on lake Ontario!
Corrected -- thanks @Mcgrupp223. Having lived across the damned thing from Toronto in Rochester for the bulk of seven years, you'd think I'd have known that. Erie's one of the Finger Lakes, right?

Image
, comment by krs10
krs10 @bl002e said:
Erie's one of the Finger Lakes, right?
Nice article. 8/9/93 was my first show and I could not for the life of me follow what was going on that night. In retrospect, I'm glad I was there, Dude, rubber chickens and all.

FYI - Lake Erie is one of the Great Lakes. Think of it this way: The Niagara River runs from Lake Erie into Lake Ontario going over Niagara Falls. They built the Welland Canal as a way around it. I was born on Lake Erie just 20mins from the Buffalo border. Nice flat country in Southern Ontario between the lakes, interrupted by the escarpment which is responsible for Niagara Falls.
, comment by mrjackstraw
mrjackstraw Nice read. I recently moved from Toronto to San Diego and cannot get back for this one unfortunately. Figures, right? Ha! Anyway, Erie is definitely a Finger Lake... or it should be at least, shallow puddle that it is...
, comment by bl002e
bl002e Thanks guys.

And for the record, my sense of the region's geography isn't that bad. Thanks to Mrs. Hall's expert instruction in the second grade, I'll always be able to rely on the HOMES mnemonic (Huron, Ontario, Michigan, Erie, Superior).

My ability to convey sarcasm via the written word, however...

, comment by krs10
krs10 @bl002e said:
Thanks guys. And for the record, my sense of the region's geography isn't that bad. Thanks to Mrs. Hall's expert instruction in the second grade, I'll always be able to rely on the HOMES mnemonic (Huron, Ontario, Michigan, Erie, Superior). My ability to convey sarcasm via the written word, however...

Ha ha, I thought you must be joking, then I second guessed... We are used to having to explain most things about our culture and country to Americans, so I took it in earnest. Glad you know about the lakes, especially since they are more than half on your side!
Thanks again for a thoughtful examination of the Canadian shows. They are very meaningful to us as the rare times we don't have to "follow the lines going south".
, comment by Mendrix
Mendrix Nice write-up. Can't wait for my first show in my home country...have only ever "followed the lines going south" as krs10 says, to NY State, although we caught GRAB in Toronto in '06. The one that got away that bother's me most is the one in my own backyard, Ottawa in '94...I just hadn't caught on to them at that point. The '99 & '00 Toronto shows I had to miss because we always attended the Ottawa Blues Fest with a gang of friends, and nobody'd follow my recommendations to go to Toronto for a band they'd only ever heard me talk about, (actually that continues to be a problem, lol). Anyways, after 3 nights of SPAC we're bringing our young girls (14 & 10) to their first Phish shows, and now I'm almost more excited for this one than SPAC, which I love. Thanks again, you've helped get me even more pumped for this with this piece.
, comment by PickeringPhish
PickeringPhish It would be great if the audience would sing O Canada at the start of the second set. Any idea how to make that happen??
, comment by OrangeSox
OrangeSox Great piece, @bl002e! Love all the hypertext, the Strange Brew detour was dope, and it was hella informative from a nerd perspective, from which i also perspect. Thanks for your time!
, comment by kipmat
kipmat Possible one-timer at Molson Ampitheater?
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Support Phish.net & Mbird
Fun with Setlists
Check our Phish setlists and sideshow setlists!
Phish News
Subscribe to Phish-News for exclusive info while on tour!


Phish.net

Phish.net is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal | DMCA

© 1990-2024  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc. | Hosted by Linode